Amity Hall Uptown

982 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025 Order now
Hero image

Serving American food in New York.

quotation

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Amity Hall Uptown Reviews on Grubhub

Michelle

Top Reviewer
I had the Angry Bird with fries. It came so nearly packaged, it was hard to believe there was food in the bag when I took it from the driver. It was double bagged, paper in plastic. I had ordered extra blue cheese and mayo. They arrived with the lids securely taped on, and no spillage at all. The food items were packaged separately, so my sandwich didn't fall all over my fries. And best of all, it was absolutely delicious!

Anmarie

Top Reviewer
Listen, I just finished my dinner, it was so good I was speechless after the first bite. I ordered the angry burger and the truffle Asiago fries, my God everything was delicious hot and crispy. Those fries I can't even describe how good. Burger cooked perfectly medium. So so fantastic. Ok I'm going to rest now with my happy tummy.

Stephanie

Top Reviewer
I got the Chipotle Mac n'Cheese with bacon and it was amazing! I've actually ordered it in the restaurant, and I think the delivery tasted better (though then I got it without bacon, so that could be the difference!). Would definitely recommend that dish.

Adara

1 review
We love the variety of dipping sauces. The fries come still relatively warm. Not all fries travel warm. Many great options for the base of the bowls

Kysha

Top Reviewer
Gorgeous burger cooked to medium as I wanted. Will order again when the mood strikes.

Reviews from Seamless.com

Amity Hall Uptown Reviews on Seamless

Kate

Top Reviewer
Loved this delivery! It's rare that fried foods get to you still hot and crunchy. I was so pleasantly surprised. Ordering for my friend is a difficult task as he is very picky. He gobbled all of this food down faster than I did. Ordered the cheese curds, calamari, jerk chicken wings, Amity burger with sweet potato fries, steak with rosemary fries. Yes, we were hungry. The money spent was well worth it.

The rosemary fries knocked my socks off. The jerk wings were a perfect blend of spicy and smokey. The steak was naturally delicious (not overwhelmed with seasoning). The cheese curds were hot and fried to perfection; they had an interesting meaty feel to them and the avocado sauce was garlicky and good. The calamari was tender and well seasoned with the perfect creamy sauce to accompany it.

My only complaint is that I found the bacon jam on the Amity burger too sweet. But I admit that by the time I took my first bite of the burger it had cooled considerably (it was piping hot when I received it), so the temperature difference might have cause a difference in taste.

I ordered the sweet potato fries because my friend is addicted to them and usually wint even touch regular fries. To my amazement he took one bite of the rosemary fries and couldn't stop eating. We didnt even make it to opening the sweet potato fries container. It was a good amount of food and after decimating the curds, calamari, half the wings, all the rosemary fries and a bit of steak we were totally done. Everything was outstanding.

I've been searching for delivery that would satisfy both of us. I am so glad I followed my gut and ordered from here. This food was delicious, the delivery was prompt, and I can't say enough about it. Will definitely order from here again!

michael

Top Reviewer
This place is great. Since its new, I checked out Yelp for tips on what to try. This is the second time I've ordered from here in the last 3 days. The chicken littles were, meh. The burger was solid. The mac and cheese was really good if you like truffle. BUT THE NACHOS- amazing! By far the best nachos I've ever had delivered (sometimes thats tricky- cold, soggy, bland, etc). They may actually be the best I've ever had period. The crema was on point and the radishes added a nice texture. Radishes, on nachos, who knew? Everything has been delivered really quickly and everything was fresh. Portions are exactly what they should be for the cost. I will 100% order from here and probably try something different each time, nothings been disappointing so far.

adrielle

Top Reviewer
Burger and fries were delicious! The mac and cheese was nasty...but I'm really picky about my mac and cheese. For that price, I expect homemade type baked deliciousness....it was like instant mac with A TON of truffle. Added bacon and even that was lack luster. And when is bacon lack luster?! But overall, will order again...just not that particular dish.

Colleen

4 reviews
I feel like everywhere we order these days there is a problem and the food sucks. This place was great. They got everything right (they even didnt forget the sauce on the side). They had a reasonable delivery time and arrived early and the food was really good. We will definitely order from here again in the future.

Neena

Top Reviewer
Super fast delivery. Food was tasty and hot. Was particularly excited to find fried cheese curds in NYC and was afraid they wouldn't deliver well but they did. My only complaint is the french fries could've been a little more well done but that's a matter of taste.

About us

Brunch, Chicken, Dinner, Hamburgers, Healthy, Lunch, Pizza, Salads, Tacos, Wings
Today
Delivery: 11:30 AM - 12:00 AM
Takeout: 12:00 PM - 12:00 AM